There is a battle brewing between dynamical and statistical models. The winner will be determined when the current neural ENSO conditions resolve into an El Nino or not in the current months.

The International Research Institute for Climate and Society compares the predictions of ensembles of each type of model here.

Although most of the set of dynamical and statistical model predictions issued during late April and early May 2012 predict continuation of neutral ENSO conditions through the middle of northern summer (i.e., June-August), slightly more than half of the models predict development of El Nino conditions around the July-September season, continuing through the remainder of 2012. Still, a sizable 40-45% of the models predict a continuation of ENSO-neutral conditions throughout 2012.

Most of the models predicting El Nino development are dynamical, while most of those predicting persistence of neutral conditions are statistical.

The figure above shows forecasts of dynamical (solid) and statistical (hollow) models for sea surface temperature (SST) in the Nino 3.4 region for nine overlapping 3-month periods. While differences among the forecasts of the models reflect both differences in model design, and actual uncertainty in the forecast of the possible future SST scenario, the divergence between dynamical and statistical models is clear.

This question fascinates me so much, I studied it for three years “Machine learning and the problem of prediction and explanation in ecological modelling” (1992). Why is there a distinction between dynamical and statistical models? What does it mean for prediction? What does it mean if one set of models are wrong?

For example, what if ENSO remains in a neutral or even La Nina state, thus ‘disproving’ the dynamical models. These models are based in the current understanding of physics (with a number of necessary approximations). Clearly this would say that something about the understanding of the climate system is wrong.

Alternatively, what if the currently neutral ENSO resolves into an El Nino, ‘disproving’ the statistical models. These models are based in past correlative relationships between variables. It would mean that some important physical feature of the system that is missing from the correlative variable has suddenly come into play.

Why should there be a distinction between dynamical and physical models at all? I have always argued that good, robust prediction requires no distinction. More precisely , the set of predictive models is at the intersection of statistical and dynamical models.

To achieve this intersection, from a starting point of a statistical model, each of the parameters and their relationships should by physically measurable. That is, if you use a simple linear regression model, each of the coefficients need to be physically measurable and the physical relationships between them additive.

From a starting point of a dynamical model, the gross, robust features of the systems should be properly described, and if necessary statistically parameterized. This usually entails a first or second order differential equation as the model.

This dynamical/statistical model is then positioned to incorporate both meaningful physical structure, and accurate correlative relationships.

It amazes me that most research models are developed along either dynamical or statistical lines, while ignoring the other.

Pingback: look what i found

Pingback: extra resources

Pingback: view how to rent a room

Pingback: Find more

Pingback: find locksmith

Pingback: sam waltonman

Pingback: click here to have your mind read

Pingback: iherb coupon code

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: iherb discount code

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: liposuction chicago cost

Pingback: Tropic wallpapers

Pingback: best rhinoplasty in nyc

Pingback: Navigate To This Website

Pingback: kenosha dentist

Pingback: play free games

Pingback: Blog

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: premature ejaculation treatment yoga exercises

Pingback: Seo

Pingback: Empowering

Pingback: News

Pingback: we hired the PA from this company

Pingback: GOPRO INDIA

Pingback: Marketing

Pingback: xbox live codes

Pingback: Tech

Pingback: elo boost

Pingback: Dr Johan Venter Urologist Pretoria urospes

Pingback: Start

Pingback: company logo design

Pingback: Health

Pingback: Top mediums van parastars voor duidelijk advies

Pingback: furnace cleaning vancouver

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: clean

Pingback: male health wellness tips

Pingback: Liberty

Pingback: Loteria Cruz Roja Resultatos

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: city

Pingback: buy congo gold from outside the bank

Pingback: mark cobb

Pingback: iherb coupon code

Pingback: Websiteoptimalisatie/klikhier/websiteoptimalisatie

Pingback: workout obsession

Pingback: Business

Pingback: read more

Pingback: soundcloud downloader

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: Vieux Nice

Pingback: Opzioni Binarie

Pingback: Technology

Pingback: reference

Pingback: Miami bankruptcy lawyer

Pingback: mieszkania warszawa

Pingback: School

Pingback: Chicago Process Servers

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: Diindolylmethane

Pingback: Fashion

Pingback: SEO Expert San Antonio TX

Pingback: dissecting microscope

Pingback: ADELGAZA 20

Pingback: more info

Pingback: tobacco e-liquid

Pingback: discount cigars

Pingback: Slotomania Free Coins For Iphone

Pingback: Financial

Pingback: visit ballsy media

Pingback: the sail at marine

Pingback: Free car insurance news online

Pingback: selcal

Pingback: Movemynt Products

Pingback: laptop

Pingback: lovelady rehab birmingham al

Pingback: LINK M88

Pingback: Affordable term life insurance rates

Pingback: new installment loans bad credit site

Pingback: vitamin c serum

Pingback: geo tv live

Pingback: top 10 proteins

Pingback: budaors elado haz

Pingback: carpet cleaning houston

Pingback: Add to Favorites

Pingback: secret money system review

Pingback: Debt

Pingback: Horses for sale

Pingback: M88

Pingback: Energy Booster

Pingback: costa rica karibikküste

Pingback: how to practice to last longer in bed

Pingback: harmen tall

Pingback: Car insurance quote online free

Pingback: Casa Ombak Ramadhan Buffet

Pingback: ebay japan

Pingback: alkaline water machine

Pingback: nutritional supplements

Pingback: fotograf poznan

Pingback: Madimo

Pingback: Legrand cariva

Pingback: Amddram