Bob Tisdale, author of the awesome book “Who Turned on the Heat?” presented an interesting problem that turns out to be a good application of robust statistical tests called empirical fluctuation processes.

Bob notes that sea surface temperature (SST) in a large region of the globe in the Eastern Pacific does not appear to have warmed at all in the last 30 years, in contrast to model simulations (CMIP SST) for that region that show strong warming. The region in question is shown below.

The question is, what is the statistical significance of the difference between model simulations and the observations? The graph comparing the models with observations from Bob’s book shows two CMIP model projections strongly increasing at 0.15C per decade for the region (brown and green) and the observations increasing at 0.006C per decade (magenta).

However, there is a lot of variability in the observations, so the natural question is whether the difference is statistically significant? A simple-minded approach would be to compare the temperature change between 1980 and 2012 relative to the standard deviation, but this would be a very low power test, and only used by someone who wanted to obfuscate the obvious failure of climate models in this region.

Empirical fluctuation processes are a natural way to examine such questions in a powerful and generalized way, as we can ask of a strongly autocorrelated series — Has there been a change in level? — without requiring the increase to be a linear trend.

To illustrate the difference, if we assume a linear regression model, as is the usual practice: Y = mt +c the statistical test for a trend is whether the trend coefficient m is greater than zero.

H0: m=0 Ha: m>0

If we test for a change in level, the EFP statistical test is whether m is constant for all of time t:

H0: mi = m0 for i over all time t.

For answering questions similar to tests of trends in linear regression, the EFP path determines if and when a simple constant model Y=m+c deviates from the data. In R this is represented as the model Y~1. If we were to use a full model Y~t then this would test whether the trend of Y is constant, not whether the level of Y is constant. This is clearer if you have run linear models in R.

Moving on to the analysis, below are the three data series given to me by Bob, and available with the R code here.

The figure below shows the series in question on the x axis, the EFP path is the black line, and 95% significance levels for the EFP path are in red.

It can be seen clearly that while the EFP path for the SST observations series shows a little unusual behavior, with a significant change in level in 1998 and again in 2005, the level is currently is not significantly above the level in 1985.

The EFP path for the CMIP3 model (CMIP5 is similar), however, exceeds the 95% significant level in 1990 and continues to increase, clearly indicating a structural increase in level in the model that has continued to intensify.

Furthermore, we can ask whether there is a change in level between the CMIP models and the SST observations. The figure below shows the EFP path for the differences CMIP3-SST and CMIP5-SST. After some deviation from zero at about 1990, around 2000 the difference becomes very significant at the 5% level, and continues to increase. Thus the EFP test shows a very significant and widening disagreement between the temperature simulation of the CMIP over the observational SST series in the Eastern Pacific region after the year 2000.

While the average of multiple model simulations show a significant change in level over the period, in the parlance of climate science, there is *not yet* a detectable change in level in the observations.

One could say I am comparing apples and oranges, as the models are average behavior while the SST observations are a single realization. But, the fact remains only the simulations of models show warming, because there is no support for warming of the region from the observations. This is consistent with the previous post on Santer’s paper showing failure of models to match the observations over most latitudinal bands.

Pingback: lån på dagen

Pingback: today you can rent that spare room with sarahomestay.com

Pingback: find locksmith

Pingback: auto locksmith

Pingback: sam waltonman

Pingback: Buy Percocet Online

Pingback: tx

Pingback: carbid kopen

Pingback: click here to unsubscribe

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: iherb coupon code

Pingback: iherb promo code

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: photopia wallpapers

Pingback: Play Free Online Games

Pingback: Hot Friv Games

Pingback: iphone hack

Pingback: Info

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: Polygraph

Pingback: premature ejaculation hypnosis free download

Pingback: Company

Pingback: giochiperragazzei.com

Pingback: giochi di guerra online gratis

Pingback: Empowering

Pingback: News

Pingback: Solutions

Pingback: Tech

Pingback: city gate singapore

Pingback: download game

Pingback: dead trigger 2 hack

Pingback: Vasant valley Nursery admissions criteria and fees

Pingback: tanki online crystal generator

Pingback: tanki online cheats

Pingback: Best SEO Programs

Pingback: Health

Pingback: Boquete Homes For Sale

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: PC Security Blog

Pingback: Liberty

Pingback: Silky hands cream

Pingback: rebelmouse.com/capturehisheartcasey

Pingback: leeds builder

Pingback: Helderzienden online: Live helderziende - Heldervoelende helderziende

Pingback: mark cobb

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: buy real gold at cheap prices from africa

Pingback: Websiteoptimalisatie/websiteoptimaliseren

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: Business

Pingback: workout obsession

Pingback: go now

Pingback: download audio songs

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: kolorowanki dla dzieci

Pingback: Camp

Pingback: New AC Spring

Pingback: opzioni binarie

Pingback: license number

Pingback: Tech

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: Social Media

Pingback: nokia pc suite usb driver

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: Miami bankruptcy lawyer

Pingback: Medical Fitness

Pingback: Process Servers in Chicago

Pingback: paintings

Pingback: Diindolylmethane

Pingback: Clothing

Pingback: alkaline water filters

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: part time jobs

Pingback: forex EA

Pingback: alkaline water machine

Pingback: paleo recipe book review

Pingback: roofing plano texas

Pingback: Financial

Pingback: Home insurance quotes

Pingback: how long does a man usually last in bed

Pingback: listen Pakistani songs online free

Pingback: auto cheap insurance news

Pingback: depression

Pingback: Mynt Products

Pingback: magic tee

Pingback: laptop

Pingback: Watch this video

Pingback: lovelady rehabilitation center in birmingham al

Pingback: LINK M88

Pingback: affordable insurance life policy

Pingback: Impeach President

Pingback: live geo news urdu

Pingback: 7 day slimming beauty plan

Pingback: kangen water ionizer

Pingback: Lien

Pingback: best whey proteins

Pingback: elado haz budaors

Pingback: immobilien leipzig

Pingback: muscle gaining secrets transformation plan

Pingback: best price services

Pingback: skulls and skeletons

Pingback: seo in pueblo Colorado

Pingback: M88

Pingback: Pokrov spiritually religious movement

Pingback: Energy Booster

Pingback: canola

Pingback: Affordable auto insurance quote

Pingback: newborn sleep

Pingback: japan shopping

Pingback: berita hari ini

Pingback: best fat loss

Pingback: rolety dzien noc

Pingback: Amddram

Pingback: rolety zewnetrzne

Pingback: free website

Pingback: test kaffeevollautomat esam 04.350.s

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Bonds

Pingback: medical treatment for premature ejaculation

Pingback: M88

Pingback: grow box

Pingback: kancelaria adwokacka rozwód szczecin

Pingback: Wp Weekend Phoenix

Pingback: Green tea

Pingback: ibc inflammatory breast cancer

Pingback: fighting games

Pingback: fajsdgjfashdjfaksjdhkfa

Pingback: men fashion accessories

Pingback: hyaluronic acid serum

Pingback: NCWISE Login

Pingback: private server

Pingback: Altieri Gilmore LLP Attorneys

Pingback: Bitcoin VPS

Pingback: medical billing software

Pingback: wondershare video editor tutorial

Pingback: gcsrdsmgkrnggkxrv

Pingback: 3d pen

Pingback: wyniki lotto

Pingback: Monsanto fears this woman

Pingback: uslugi ksiegowe kraków

Pingback: chicken coop ideas

Pingback: cd dvd label software