There appears to be an error in the influential paper by Rahmstorf et al. (2007). Rahmstorf et.al. (Science Brevia, 4 May 2007, p709 [1]) reports that the trend of the global mean of surface temperature and sea level raise concerns that the climate system “may be responding more quickly to climate change than our current generation of models indicates”. At least one major study, Interim Report of the Garnaut Review, relies on the paper for advocating prompt and extreme action on carbon emissions, one of its major conclusions (Section 2.4 Consequences of Climate Change, Observed Climate Change). But there seems to be a problem.

As previously reported here,

the conclusions of Rahmstorf’s 7 (Rahmstorf, Cazenave, Church, Hansen, Keeling, Parker, and Somerville) rely on a trend line lying above the IPCC projections on their Figure 1, shown enlarged below. No statistical tests are performed, the basis for their claim is purely based on the visual aid. Their Figure 1 is below, with the key part of the image containing the IPCC projection enlarged.

**Figures 1 and 2: Rahmstorf et al. (2007) Figure 1. Whole and enlarged.**

Rahmstorf’s 7 state in the figure caption that

“All trends are nonlinear trend lines

and are computed with an embedding period of 11 years

and a minimum roughness criterion at the end (Moore

et.al. 2006 [2])”. On reading Moore’s paper, it would

appear the nonlinear methodology used was Singular

Spectrum Analysis (SSA). The Moore paper suggests the

minimum roughness criterion (MRC) would follow the

Mann 2004 [3] recipe of padding the end of the series with

data reflected about the final value.

**Figure 3 and 4: GISS temperature with SSA trend, unpadded and padded.**

The peculiar property of MRC of “pinning” the trend line

to the final end point of the series has been noted in

a post “Mannomatic Smoothing and Pinned End-points” at ClimateAudit.

The comparison of MRC and non-MRC padded series

is shown in figures captured from CaterpillarSSA.

The first figure “unpadded.png” shows

a SSA trend line that approximates the Rahmstorf figure result. The

second figure “padded.png” shows the SSA trend line with an MRC

padded GISS series, passing directly through the 2006

value. This is as it should be, as the MRC effectively

‘pins’ the trend line to the final value due to the

symmetry about the final value.

Was a direct application

of the SSA trend line used and not an MRC padded series

as described?

If an MRC padded series had been used in the figure,

it would have been end-pinned to the 2006 value,

at the center of the IPCC

projections. The figure would then not have conveyed the

impression that temperatures are in the upper range of

the IPCC projections, as claimed.

As it was in 2006, it appears that SSA

without MRC padding produces a higher trend line than

with MRC padding, necessary for supporting their claim.

An additional puzzling factor is the reference to MRC padding

at all. Padding the end of the series is not actually

necessary to ensure a SSA trend line is drawn to the

end of the series values. Padding is only necessary in

acausal filters such as moving averages that stop a

window length short of the end of the series.

To date, attempts to contact Prof. Rahmstorf and clarify the actual methodology

used have been unsuccessful.

## References

[1]Stefan Rahmstorf, Anny Cazenave, John A. Church, James E. Hansen,

Ralph F. Keeling, David E. Parker, and Richard C. J. Somerville. Recent

Climate Observations Compared to Projections. Science, 316(5825):709â€“,

2007.

[2] A. Grinsted Moore, J.C. and S. Jevrejeva. New tools for analyzing time series relationships and trends. Eos, 86(24), 1995.

[3] M. E. Mann. On smoothing potentially non-stationary climate time series.

Geophys. Res. Lett., 31:L07214, doi:10.1029/2004GL019569 2004.

Pingback: Real Climate Tries to Spin Pielke: A curious lesson 2. | The Blackboard

Pingback: Niche Modeling » Rahmstorf et al. 2007 Update

Pingback: Niche Modeling » Examples of simple smoothers

Pingback: Niche Modeling » Rahmstorf 7 Finale

Pingback: Blog-Reviews « Climate Review

Pingback: Niche Modeling » Garnaut Report Due

Pingback: Math101 – Filtering Theory » Blog Archive » Moore et al. 2005

Pingback: sam waltonman

Pingback: clik here html

Pingback: top nyc plastic surgeons

Pingback: highline residences by keppel

Pingback: linkedin ipo

Pingback: kenosha dentist

Pingback: regenerative institute

Pingback: Click here

Pingback: Friv Games

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: Lie detection Denver Colorado

Pingback: ????????? ???????????? ??????????? ???????????

Pingback: xylocaine gel for premature ejaculation

Pingback: Business Marketing Tools

Pingback: buy GOpro in Delhi

Pingback: Soccer Fundraiser

Pingback: Start

Pingback: escritorio de advocacia

Pingback: web directory list

Pingback: graphic design

Pingback: Health

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: muscle maximizer

Pingback: Liberty

Pingback: licence-referencement.fr

Pingback: pelata kolikkopelit

Pingback: shipping parcel

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: mark cobb

Pingback: workout obsession

Pingback: Business

Pingback: how to download from soundcloud

Pingback: Camp

Pingback: ubrania dla dzieci

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: Technology

Pingback: Laptop

Pingback: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=air.com.mysweet.dog

Pingback: Pregnancy

Pingback: Home

Pingback: Diindolylmethane

Pingback: We Buy Houses in Lyme, CT

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: Music Producer

Pingback: billig guenstig

Pingback: custom app developers

Pingback: San Antonio TX SEO Consultants

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: gu10 led bulbs

Pingback: water ionizers

Pingback: dissecting microscope

Pingback: Splinter Cell Blacklist Trainer

Pingback: San Diego SEO Experts

Pingback: metatrader ea programming

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: alkaline water machine

Pingback: jak oszukac automaty hazardowe

Pingback: heroes of camelot hack

Pingback: kratom bestellen

Pingback: see

Pingback: Slotomania Free Coins 2013

Pingback: roofing Athens Ga

Pingback: how to last longer in missionary

Pingback: Free Facebook Likes

Pingback: low self esteem

Pingback: Hunter Valley Website Design

Pingback: knights and dragons cheats

Pingback: Naperville IL Homes for Sale

Pingback: Movemynt Products

Pingback: vitamin c for face

Pingback: Impeach the President

Pingback: geo news tv live in urdu

Pingback: click site

Pingback: kangen water

Pingback: gw1516

Pingback: duct cleaning houton

Pingback: gothic products

Pingback: social media management

Pingback: aceite de canola

Pingback: Best dentist in Cambridge

Pingback: ebay japan

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Fakro

Pingback: paul pogba

Pingback: laptop backpack

Pingback: marketing

Pingback: dieta na mase

Pingback: Property By Owner List Commercial Lease Jacksonville FL

Pingback: paleo recipe book review

Pingback: M88

Pingback: Template

Pingback: No down payment mortgage

Pingback: cong ty thiet ke web

Pingback: Wp Weekend Phoenix

Pingback: this site has good information

Pingback: Best Web Hosting Services

Pingback: Recovery Best

Pingback: Taxi

Pingback: where to stay at boracay

Pingback: fajsdgjfashdjfaksjdhkfa

Pingback: austin dentists

Pingback: Altieri Gilmore LLP Attorneys

Pingback: Contractors in Dallas

Pingback: free medical billing software

Pingback: www.americanshifter.com

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Business

Pingback: Girls' Sandals

Pingback: Pen Scratch Remover

Pingback: mice infection

Pingback: SizeGenetics Ultimate Extension System

Pingback: News

Pingback: Denver DUI Attorney

Pingback: Less expensive Shopping Online

Pingback: expendables 3 for free

Pingback: Java Tutorial Point

Pingback: teeth whitening fast

Pingback: Indian food caterer in Singapore

Pingback: helpful hints

Pingback: la verdad del sureste

Pingback: myfreecam token hack

Pingback: Movies Trailer

Pingback: trusted tablets

Pingback: download film the expendables 3 subtitles indonesia

Pingback: see here now

Pingback: Creativity tips

Pingback: telugu The Expendables 3 download

Pingback: kannada The Expendables 3 download

Pingback: Puppy Separation Anxiety Solution

Pingback: The Expendables 3 for download

Pingback: visit homepage,

Pingback: think and grow rich online book

Pingback: what to eat for people with diabetes

Pingback: sacred 3 trainer

Pingback: sklepy internetowe warszawa

Pingback: download The Expendables 3

Pingback: belki zadania

Pingback: download The Expendables 3

Pingback: JPC Law

Pingback: utorrent download The Expendables 3

Pingback: cortinas

Pingback: cheap vegas show tickets

Pingback: Homepage of Nepal

Pingback: continue reading this

Pingback: free jquery mobile templates

Pingback: marynarki meskie

Pingback: Metal detector

Pingback: being young

Pingback: how can you last longer in bed naturally

Pingback: seo companies

Pingback: ancient agate

Pingback: plumbers in okc

Pingback: Logistics

Pingback: internet

Pingback: kargo

Pingback: warehouses miami

Pingback: phone repair

Pingback: Best tanning Lotion

Pingback: fha loan Dunwoody

Pingback: jumbo loans Lawrenceville

Pingback: epic fails 2014

Pingback: paddle hair brush

Pingback: dvd

Pingback: submit a press release

Pingback: buy youtube views

Pingback: quality products

Pingback: Handbags

Pingback: Eliminate Your Tinnitus Forever In 30-60 Days - Guaranteed!

Pingback: mykneescooter

Pingback: Coinapult

Pingback: vao m88

Pingback: paleo recipe book

Pingback: kaffeevollautomat wmf 800

Pingback: advogado sp

Pingback: chevy sierra fender flares

Pingback: entertainment news

Pingback: criminal lawyer

Pingback: fiverr backlinks

Pingback: zhunrize

Pingback: karaoke birmingham chinatown

Pingback: Best slimming ebook

Pingback: paddle hair brush

Pingback: $1000 Profit in 30 Minute Proven Binary Trading Strategy

Pingback: LA CAN

Pingback: Same Day Service

Pingback: william hill free bet

Pingback: sky floating lanterns

Pingback: Rodos

Pingback: mode

Pingback: reviews of Green Smoke

Pingback: silicone needles

Pingback: Abe Debaca

Pingback: Coupon Codes

Pingback: Discount coupons

Pingback: review

Pingback: sanook

Pingback: game

Pingback: Bangalore Film

Pingback: Verified Forex Binary Education

Pingback: debt consolidation

Pingback: Dating Love

Pingback: korea travel tips

Pingback: heartburn diet

Pingback: habanos

Pingback: online massage courses

Pingback: Find Whos Calling

Pingback: cigar one

Pingback: cigars

Pingback: buy cuban cigars

Pingback: BREIL

Pingback: ezra mu online

Pingback: relax melodies

Pingback: DontPingMe.com Web, News Tricks

Pingback: Network Marketing Training

Pingback: instagram users search engine

Pingback: LIve Scores

Pingback: Chicago Wedding Cinematographer

Pingback: how can i get taller

Pingback: forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=538591

Pingback: Sneak A Peek At This Web-Site.

Pingback: host then profit

Pingback: Trading

Pingback: Portland personal injury attorney

Pingback: sacred geometry

Pingback: YEPI 123

Pingback: eventi piemonte

Pingback: Countertop Installation

Pingback: Our Web Page

Pingback: discount shakeology

Pingback: action figures

Pingback: great powerpoint presentations 2014

Pingback: wholesale makeup

Pingback: unblocked games

Pingback: vorzeitiger samenerguss

Pingback: wholesale cosmetics list

Pingback: chicago used cars

Pingback: cna certification

Pingback: Skip Tracing

Pingback: Houston TX For Sale By Owner

Pingback: best trading system

Pingback: Betboo

Pingback: cialise medicament

Pingback: Whatsapp Hack

Pingback: Make Money Online

Pingback: dog training camp

Pingback: pest control houston review

Pingback: uslugi premium

Pingback: Whatsapp Hack

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: African and Global Business

Pingback: openappmkt

Pingback: New Life ESL Reviews

Pingback: projektowanie wnetrz kraków

Pingback: new home purchase

Pingback: slots machines games for free

Pingback: escort izmir

Pingback: notepad bluebox

Pingback: m?s info

Pingback: film izle

Pingback: pet supply distributors

Pingback: marmaris transfers

Pingback: Group

Pingback: website shop

Pingback: teen dating site

Pingback: giochi di cucina online

Pingback: slots games online free

Pingback: cialis

Pingback: how can i get my boyfriend to last longer in bed

Pingback: livejasmin credits gratuit

Pingback: kitchen fitters york uk

Pingback: banana blue

Pingback: screen protector for iphone 6

Pingback: perth web designer

Pingback: Yes I Make Money and You Can Too

Pingback: iks66 donations

Pingback: divorce lawyer in maryland

Pingback: loyal 9 marketing

Pingback: arkitekter

Pingback: Jeep parts

Pingback: Hack Facebook Account

Pingback: posciel

Pingback: konverteringsoptimering

Pingback: Business Development

Pingback: cheap orange beach beach Rentals

Pingback: Calculate the date of birth online

Pingback: stopthestresstoday.com/about-me

Pingback: This is an example of an automaticly updating blog

Pingback: Interlink

Pingback: Cleaners Sydney

Pingback: Paperless Solutions

Pingback: harlem

Pingback: emergency plumbing

Pingback: online jobs

Pingback: projekty domów

Pingback: air conditioning repair magnolia

Pingback: kangen

Pingback: Scheidungsanwalt Haag

Pingback: Buy Instagram Followers

Pingback: Illuminati in south Africa

Pingback: your input here

Pingback: Chelsie Mayeshiba

Pingback: centrum czesci

Pingback: www.homebasedjobsinsights.com/finding-legit-work-at-home-jobs/

Pingback: suv accident