Below are my replications of Figure 4 and Figure 5 of the controversial paper “Influence of the Southern Oscillation on tropospheric temperature” by J. D. McLean, C. R. de Freitas, and R. M. Carter.

Above is the comparison of global atmospheric temperature (RATPAC-A) with the SOI, smoothed with a flat 12 month filter.

Above is the comparison of the 12 month differences (not derivative) of global atmospheric temperature (RATPAC-A) (lagged) with the SOI, smoothed with a flat 12 month filter.

I found a 2 month lag gave an optimal alignment. The regression output below shows an R2 of 0.52. I don’t know if that is what they got for this particular data combination, but it is in the same ballpark.

source("script.R")

figrep()

```
```Call:

lm(formula = d$ddGTTA ~ d$dSOI)

Residuals:

Min 1Q Median 3Q Max

-0.55874 -0.08093 0.01564 0.09929 0.40064

Coefficients:

Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)

(Intercept) 0.0085806 0.0060261 1.424 0.155

d$dSOI 0.0158019 0.0006306 25.059 <2e-16 ***

---

Signif. codes: 0 â€˜***â€™ 0.001 â€˜**â€™ 0.01 â€˜*â€™ 0.05 â€˜.â€™ 0.1 â€˜ â€™ 1

`Residual standard error: 0.1447 on 575 degrees of freedom`

Multiple R-squared: 0.522, Adjusted R-squared: 0.5212

F-statistic: 628 on 1 and 575 DF, p-value: < 2.2e-16

At this point I am satisfied that they did what they said they did, that I know what they have done, and that the correlations they report are actually there.

Pingback: sam waltonman

Pingback: mug shots

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: somanabolic muscle maximizer reviews

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: munchs wallpapers

Pingback: nose doctor nyc

Pingback: highline residences tiong bahru

Pingback: Gamble

Pingback: URL

Pingback: free web cams

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: premature ejaculation lubricant

Pingback: School Fundraiser

Pingback: Start

Pingback: Health

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: the muscle maximizer

Pingback: Liberty

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: gopro hero 3

Pingback: iherb coupon code

Pingback: iherb coupon code

Pingback: mark cobb

Pingback: kurs paralotniarstwa

Pingback: new books on lung cancer

Pingback: Camp

Pingback: pizamy dzieciece

Pingback: how to detox your body

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: bankruptcy attorney Miami

Pingback: Tech

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: Primerica financial services scam

Pingback: Diindolylmethane

Pingback: We Buy Houses in Branford, CT

Pingback: Fashion

Pingback: SEO Expert San Diego CA

Pingback: Pressure Cooking Recipes

Pingback: Expert Advisor

Pingback: global travel

Pingback: petsitters in naples

Pingback: paleo recipe book review

Pingback: buy e-liquid

Pingback: Pest Control Decatur, GA

Pingback: Mynt Products

Pingback: selcal

Pingback: lovelady center in birmingham al

Pingback: magazin online

Pingback: siting

Pingback: Wheaton IL Homes For Sale

Pingback: hHmes For Sale Downers Grove IL

Pingback: cambogia garcinia

Pingback: all inclusive cancun resorts

Pingback: framed shower doors houston

Pingback: backpacking europe

Pingback: dryer cleaning houston

Pingback: muscle gaining secrets 2.0

Pingback: secret money system

Pingback: forum

Pingback: how can i last longer in bed men

Pingback: groom speech advice

Pingback: online dating

Pingback: Mimaki

Pingback: how to get a guy to last longer

Pingback: woodworking projects

Pingback: Ramadhan Buffet Casa Ombak

Pingback: courier insurance

Pingback: kangen alkaline water

Pingback: berita hari ini

Pingback: massage continuing education online

Pingback: rozliczanie podatku z niemiec

Pingback: poswiadczenie dziedziczenia Wroclaw

Pingback: Property By Owner List Foreclosed Real Estate Long Beach CA

Pingback: 24 Hour Bail Bonds

Pingback: paleo recipe book review

Pingback: how to fix premature ejaculation naturally

Pingback: her imports

Pingback: thiet ke website

Pingback: Silver Sulfa diazine cream

Pingback: Wp Weekend Phoenix

Pingback: Power Data Recovery

Pingback: browse this website

Pingback: Top Web Hosting Services

Pingback: various posts

Pingback: Taxi

Pingback: play zombies

Pingback: fajsdgjfashdjfaksjdhkfa

Pingback: best pay per click company

Pingback: Pro 2014

Pingback: asic miners

Pingback: see this here

Pingback: Samsung Galaxy 4

Pingback: free medical billing software

Pingback: krakowianian

Pingback: drzwi aluminiowe

Pingback: meble dla szkól

Pingback: 3d filaments

Pingback: koraliki do bizuterii

Pingback: Montblanc Pen Polish

Pingback: WP Dollar 2

Pingback: chicken coop ideas

Pingback: supply chain management

Pingback: home interiors

Pingback: online therapist for anxiety

Pingback: News

Pingback: Comparison Shopping Website

Pingback: Learn More Here

Pingback: expendables 3 full movie

Pingback: Java Tutorials

Pingback: get a job at mcdonalds

Pingback: gogol spain

Pingback: sites

Pingback: how to prevent premature ejaculation video

Pingback: Source

Pingback: daily news

Pingback: gta 5 full

Pingback: download film expendables 3 3gp

Pingback: download film the expendables 3 sub indo

Pingback: her response

Pingback: new The Expendables 3 download free

Pingback: 3gp The Expendables 3 download

Pingback: Puppy Separation Anxiety Cures

Pingback: Go Here

Pingback: Miles fit

Pingback: safety inspectors

Pingback: Free Expendables 3

Pingback: downloading The Expendables 3

Pingback: download The Expendables 3

Pingback: online email video marketing

Pingback: last 29 minutes longer in bed

Pingback: go here,

Pingback: download The Expendables 3 for free

Pingback: http://excursionesparahacerentenerife.tumblr.com/

Pingback: jaffe porter crossick

Pingback: kasacja pojazdów

Pingback: Advertise your business

Pingback: buy betta fish online

Pingback: you can look here

Pingback: payday borrowing in uk

Pingback: boligindretning

Pingback: isohunt download The Expendables 3

Pingback: arkitektforbundet

Pingback: restaurant

Pingback: look younger

Pingback: bankruptcy

Pingback: mini vibrator

Pingback: Colusa criminal attorney

Pingback: warehouses miami

Pingback: click here

Pingback: Best tanning Lotion

Pingback: wet cunt

Pingback: water ionizers

Pingback: epic fails

Pingback: Press Release

Pingback: quality products

Pingback: funny commercials

Pingback: pain management doctors houston tx

Pingback: Solar PV

Pingback: paleo recipe book

Pingback: coal tar shampoo

Pingback: stylish pet products

Pingback: christian store

Pingback: criminal lawyer

Pingback: Pool Design Ideas

Pingback: fiverr backlinks

Pingback: Appliance

Pingback: education

Pingback: Water Heater Repair Denver

Pingback: sports video games skill games advertising

Pingback: Chicago appliance repair service

Pingback: minoxidil

Pingback: ANAL

Pingback: shooting game

Pingback: ??δ?σε??

Pingback: mspy review

Pingback: natural treatment for premature ejaculation

Pingback: vogelperspektive

Pingback: kabuki foundation brush

Pingback: Online Gambling in Asia

Pingback: Review of ultimate street fighter 4

Pingback: vitiligo new cure

Pingback: managed servers

Pingback: biotin for keranique for hair loss dr oz

Pingback: corset

Pingback: Forex Education course

Pingback: play online roulette

Pingback: first sax

Pingback: jazz flute

Pingback: coffee health

Pingback: pregnancy tracker app

Pingback: habanos cuban cigars

Pingback: reviews of GreenSmoke

Pingback: New Songs

Pingback: cuban cigars online

Pingback: cuban cigars switzerland

Pingback: massage continuing education online

Pingback: Become a Simpsons character!

Pingback: escorts london

Pingback: drinks brasilia

Pingback: erotik cam

Pingback: buy cuban cigars online

Pingback: Lookup by Phone

Pingback: Yun Wanda

Pingback: www.amazon.com/garcinia-cambogia-extract

Pingback: Try What She Says

Pingback: the perfect match

Pingback: kain batik

Pingback: Quantum Leap Your Network Marketing Business

Pingback: romance books for 7th graders

Pingback: click here now

Pingback: Boulevard3

Pingback: kargo

Pingback: cccam server

Pingback: M88

Pingback: Popcorn Removal

Pingback: what to eat to last longer in bed

Pingback: accident attorney Portland

Pingback: metatron cube

Pingback: orinda california Ipé decks

Pingback: YEPI 123

Pingback: guess emoji

Pingback: CLASH OF CLANS UNLIMITED GEMS

Pingback: special info

Pingback: Illinois Flat Fee MLS

Pingback: shakeology review bad

Pingback: sports

Pingback: Mayweather vs Maidana

Pingback: vorzeitiger samenerguss

Pingback: mazda cx 9

Pingback: new york house cleaning service

Pingback: cheap computers

Pingback: Simple document list every borrower needs to know

Pingback: eye testing

Pingback: eye tests

Pingback: Seriale Subtitrate Romana

Pingback: Halifax Real Estate for sale

Pingback: dog poop bags bulk

Pingback: For Sale By Owner Charlotte NC

Pingback: For Sale By Owner Mesa AZ

Pingback: ice bucket challenge fail

Pingback: watch geo news live high quality

Pingback: weight lifting equipment

Pingback: is there medication for premature ejaculation

Pingback: bets10

Pingback: bee wild pest control

Pingback: ice bucket challenge

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: African and Global Business

Pingback: projektowanie wnetrz kraków

Pingback: buy hydrocodone

Pingback: projektowanie sklepów internetowych lódz

Pingback: notepad bluebox

Pingback: online slot machine games for free

Pingback: bid on and win hot

Pingback: softball

Pingback: videosincestovip.blogspot.com.es

Pingback: emotional intelligence training

Pingback: sinema izle

Pingback: videos de mamadas

Pingback: international courier services in india

Pingback: these details

Pingback: my boyfriend has premature ejaculation

Pingback: free slot games download

Pingback: dubai angels

Pingback: Ipas Empower Network Review

Pingback: wine auction

Pingback: teen network

Pingback: driving theory test for uk

Pingback: Lettings agent surbiton

Pingback: szkolenie bhp

Pingback: Forum PC

Pingback: Rentoboende Städfirma

Pingback: seo marketing

Pingback: seo website

Pingback: banana blue

Pingback: epic fails

Pingback: Sell your house Phoenix

Pingback: pva

Pingback: How to Make Money With a Website or Blog

Pingback: musical meditation

Pingback: substitute xylitol for sugar

Pingback: hecigarette review

Pingback: learn more

Pingback: Chrome OS

Pingback: kulturystyka

Pingback: funny vines

Pingback: Personal Development

Pingback: Click here

Pingback: warszawa dochodwe pozycjonowanie semstar

Pingback: arkitekter

Pingback: Livejasmin Hack no survey no password

Pingback: payment gateway development

Pingback: anderson roofing fort worth tx

Pingback: Ariel Gandeza

Pingback: inbound marketing

Pingback: Wigs Denver

Pingback: Hair Transplant

Pingback: distance

Pingback: alldoza.net/beatstore

Pingback: teeth grills for sale

Pingback: Search links