A concerned reader sent me this recent paper Water-vapor climate feedback inferred from climate fluctuations, 2003-2008, writing:

The following (ala Hansen) IMO should never have been accepted in a "peer reviewed" journal. "The existence of a strong and positive water-vapor feedback means that projected business-as-usual greenhouse gas emissions over the next century are virtually guaranteed to produce warming of several degrees Celsius. The only way that will not happen is if a strong, negative, and currently unknown feedback is discovered somewhere in our climate system."

After my previous post on detecting research bias by checking if the data justify the conclusions, this looked like a good candidate — no significance test, very few data points, idiosyncratic methodology, and bold claims. So I ran some significance tests (R script here).

Would someone like to read the paper and check the logic behind my choice of tests? Its very short.

Using data on water vapor and temperature fluctuations between 2003-2008 collected by the NASA satellite AIRS, Dessler et al. 2008 claim independent confirmation of a strongly positive feedback in the specific humidity parameter λ_{q} of 2.04W/m/K. However, they did not calculate an uncertainty for this value, raising the question of whether the results are distinguishable from the null hypothesis of no water-vapor feedback.

The values of the specific humidity feedback parameter λ_{q} for each of years 2003-2007 relative to year 2008 were 2.10, 2.69, 1.77, 2.69, and 0.94 W/m/K respectively. Direct calculation of the standard deviation of the five data poinst suggests an sd=0.73 with a standard error of 0.37, giving a lower limit to the 95% confidence interval of 1.32 — much greater than zero. However, this approach does not consider the way λ_{q} was calculated relative to a single 2008 value. The uncertainty in the 2008 value must be taken into account in estimating the range of the difference between the anomalous year of 2008 and the other years.

To incorporate the true uncertainty of the difference of two uncertain values, we use a t-test of the difference of means of unequal samples with equal variance. This will incorporate both the variance of the sample of five feedback values, and a sample of one value, zero, assumed to have the same variance as the sample of five. This test yields a t value of 2.54, which at 4 degrees of freedom gives a *p* value of 0.033, slightly larger than the *p*=0.025 critical value required for a conventional one-tailed test to be significant at the 95% confidence level. Below are the *p* values for other non-parametric tests of the difference of means.

Test | P | Significant |
---|---|---|

t.test | 0.03 | NS |

Kruskal | 0.14 | NS |

Wilcox | 0.33 | NS |

All *p* values listed in Table 1 indicate the alternative hypothesis, that water-vapor feedback is significantly greater than zero, falls short of the conventional 95% confidence level. The probability the results arose by chance is high, largely due to a methodology relying on one anomalous year as a reference point. Therefore Dessler et al. 2008 provides no credible justification for claims of the “existence of a strong and positive feedback ” which is “virtually guaranteed to produce warming of several degrees Celsius” (in this century).

Pingback: sam waltonman

Pingback: click here to activate your account

Pingback: www.blackhatlinks.com

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: exitosa wallpapers

Pingback: doctors nyc

Pingback: highline residences tiong bahru

Pingback: kenosha dentists

Pingback: Friv Games

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: Lie detection Denver Colorado

Pingback: ??????????? ??????????? ? ??????

Pingback: anti premature ejaculation chomikuj

Pingback: Social Media Marketing Tools

Pingback: lol boost

Pingback: xovilichter

Pingback: sm slaaf in

Pingback: School Fundraising

Pingback: Throne Rush Gems free

Pingback: Advogado familia

Pingback: Start

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: clean

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: licence-referencement.fr

Pingback: Liberty

Pingback: pelata kolikkopelit

Pingback: hairy anus

Pingback: alkaline ionized water

Pingback: congo gold is best

Pingback: Business

Pingback: mark cobb

Pingback: iherb coupon codes

Pingback: workout obsession

Pingback: home

Pingback: iherb coupon codes

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: Camp

Pingback: nice06000

Pingback: mattress for reflux

Pingback: how to detox your body naturally

Pingback: fifa 13 coins

Pingback: Tech

Pingback: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=air.com.mysweet.dog

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: Weight Loss

Pingback: Diindolylmethane

Pingback: Clothing

Pingback: app developers

Pingback: water ionizers

Pingback: Stereoscope microscope

Pingback: adelgaza 20

Pingback: part time jobs

Pingback: Silver Buyers

Pingback: roofing contractors plano tx

Pingback: Financial

Pingback: voyeurism

Pingback: brenda spahn

Pingback: Movemynt Products

Pingback: class e airspace

Pingback: Logo design

Pingback: installment loans with bad credit cheap

Pingback: Plainfield IL Real Estate

Pingback: air quality houston

Pingback: MLS Listings Illinois

Pingback: grimms fairy tales script

Pingback: muscle gaining secrets 2.0

Pingback: bhw

Pingback: easiest way to last longer in bed

Pingback: Medical Daily

Pingback: Number Plates

Pingback: M88

Pingback: Buy Twitter Followers

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: stargazer tinte comprar

Pingback: how to become an emt

Pingback: kitchen design ideas

Pingback: anabolic cookbook

Pingback: Casa Ombak Buffet Ramadhan

Pingback: banner designers

Pingback: alkaline water testimonials

Pingback: diets

Pingback: massage ceus

Pingback: Legacy Food Storage

Pingback: odwolanie do zus

Pingback: Drukarnia Madimo

Pingback: Amddram

Pingback: Weight Loss

Pingback: autoskup040.pl lublin

Pingback: biuro rachunkowe radom

Pingback: Rowery elektryczne

Pingback: kaffeevollautomat test pads

Pingback: how to get a guy to last longer

Pingback: Bail Bonds Zero Down

Pingback: ro water

Pingback: paleo recipe book review

Pingback: air conditioning repair cypress

Pingback: Cheat

Pingback: Wp Weekend Phoenix

Pingback: Wp Weekend Phoenix

Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

Pingback: Green tea

Pingback: www.legacyfoodstorage.com

Pingback: iberostar tucan

Pingback: kasinospel

Pingback: Private number plates

Pingback: zombie me.com

Pingback: email marketing tips

Pingback: fajsdgjfashdjfaksjdhkfa

Pingback: men fashion clothing

Pingback: NCWISE Login

Pingback: 332 Se Douglas St. Lee's Summit, MO 64063

Pingback: Altieri Gilmore LLP Attorneys

Pingback: Classic

Pingback: see this

Pingback: lenam wspracie w sprzedazy

Pingback: hotele Elblag

Pingback: hurtownie fryzjerskie

Pingback: win prizes like Wii and ipod, it's fast, easy and fun. join us

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: wondershare video editor

Pingback: autokary warszawa

Pingback: Growing your own food lis like printing your own money

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: Jewelry

Pingback: WP Dollar

Pingback: chicken coop ideas

Pingback: cd label maker freeware

Pingback: how to get rid of mice