**Admin:** Posted up for Steve, with an initial response by Miklos. The slides Steve referred to are here. My bad for not telling Miklos that.

Link to TF&K08

Miskolczi theory proposes a tau (Ta if you will) significantly different from that found by at least a dozen other studies published in the peer-reviewed literature over more than a decade, as well as a number of other new relations A_A = E_D, f = 2/3 etc., etc.

In the scientific processes I have been involved myself a number of times, to resolve why one one or more studies get one or more critical parameter values significantly different from most other studies, a process is entered into whereby those who are getting the significantly different values have to demonstrate why that should be so. If their explanation proves good enough, and is verified/validated it usually results in a shift in the accepted values. This is just part of the normal processes of the advancement of scientific knowledge.

If this is not the case with Miskolczi then this is no better than the IPCC. I propose the following questions:

(1) Explain why neither Slides 68 or 69 explicitly state clear sky and all sky global means are being dealt with (respectively) as Nick has suggested is the case (and I concur seems the most likely interpretation).

(2) Confirm he is indeed referring to a global clear sky mean when he shows a slide (Slide 68) claiming the S_T = 90.7 W/m^2 and then explain why he simultaneously claims in the very same slide that K&T97 (known clear sky S_T ~100 W/m^2) is in error by 22.5 W/m^2!

(3) Identify which peer reviewed publication the interpretation given in Slide 70 claiming the Miskolczi HARTCODE interpretation of the NOAA 60 year average gives S_T = 60.9 W/m^2 appears when the AGW consensus is for a global all sky S_T of ~40 W/m^2 even as recently as F,T&K08 (which reviews/summarizes the finding of other radiative codes).

The bottom line is that Miskolczi is saying there is a ‘magic tau’ of magnitude 1.87. He has consistently got this by using a B anywhere from about 396 down to about 380 W/m^2 yet somehow the S_T values he gets at the same time always stays in the range of about 63 down to 58.5 W/m^2, resulting in a tau in the range 1.84 – 1.87 (say).

To accept Miskolczi Theory as viable we need to be technically very clear on why there is always this discrepancy where the Miskolczi S_T is always significantly greater by about 20 – 25 W/m^2 than the accepted literature range of values – from numerous studies – most using good radiative codes and putting great effort into correctly weighting the land and oceanic all sky values in order to derive a global mean.

We also need to understand why the Miskolczi S_T always appears to be much closer to the accepted literature range of values for net LW up i.e. the sum of S_T and that LW IR emitted upwards by clouds. Sheer coincidence? I would hope so.

## Miklos Zagoni responds:

Here are some answers to Steve.

1. I do not know which of my presentations are you talking about, but as you all know, the clear-sky g is 1/3 while the all-sky global average is about 0.4. From the numbers one always able to figure out whether clear or all sky calculation is displayed.

2. The slide that gives you the KT97 22.5Wm-2 error, is calculated (as is written there) at their (reduced) h2o content. With those amounts of GHG in the air, Hartcode says that their St should be 90.7. But they (as they admitted) regarded only the WIN (833-1250 cm-1) region.

3. AGW consensus of St=40 rests on the mentioned KT97. Please point to the locus please in KT97, or TFK08 where they give the details beyond it.

Please give me also any indication how TFK08, or anyone else, measured the atmospheric window radiation.

Thanks,

Miklos

Pingback: sam waltonman

Pingback: best background check

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: iherb discount code

Pingback: Related Resources, Follow this link:

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: Play Free Games Online

Pingback: 24 hour locksmith houston Texas

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: sex on cam

Pingback: steps to cure premature ejaculation

Pingback: Affiliate Marketing Tools

Pingback: Nikon d3200 Body only price in India

Pingback: link

Pingback: Fundraising

Pingback: List of schools in Central delhi

Pingback: Advogado familia

Pingback: Start

Pingback: graphic design

Pingback: Health

Pingback: clean

Pingback: Finance

Pingback: the muscle maximizer

Pingback: Liberty

Pingback: capture his heart review

Pingback: mark cobb

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: york

Pingback: iherb coupons

Pingback: workout obsession

Pingback: download free music

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: Active Roleplayers Group - Browse through active roleplayers

Pingback: iherb coupon

Pingback: Camp

Pingback: ubrania dla dzieci

Pingback: Opzioni Binarie

Pingback: Technology

Pingback: nokia pc suite x2-01 free download

Pingback: Custom Street Signs Dallas TX

Pingback: Diindolylmethane

Pingback: clash of clans cheats

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: Fashion

Pingback: custom app developers

Pingback: water ionizer comparisons

Pingback: part time job

Pingback: need more information

Pingback: SEO Expert San Diego CA

Pingback: paleo recipe book review

Pingback: quit smoking

Pingback: kratom wiki

Pingback: how to get slotomania free coins

Pingback: Omen Interactive

Pingback: HD video Pakistani songs

Pingback: class e airspace

Pingback: Core Products

Pingback: magic tee

Pingback: Click here

Pingback: under sea tours

Pingback: lovelady center website

Pingback: creare site

Pingback: Free Facebook Likes

Pingback: great loans

Pingback: near naples florida

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: geo news latest

Pingback: have a peek at these guys

Pingback: kangen water ionizer

Pingback: pain doctor houston tx

Pingback: muscle gaining secrets transformation

Pingback: best price services

Pingback: secret money system review

Pingback: seizure forum

Pingback: groom speech

Pingback: liposuction surgery

Pingback: canon

Pingback: paint horse for sale

Pingback: M88

Pingback: how long is premature ejaculation

Pingback: news about hollywood stars

Pingback: berita hari ini

Pingback: burning fat fast

Pingback: napedy do bram przemyslowych

Pingback: waclaw berent

Pingback: Legrand cariva

Pingback: Amddram

Pingback: search engine portal

Pingback: Weight Loss Surgery

Pingback: http://gry-przegladarkowe.net.pl/

Pingback: instalacje gazowe poznan

Pingback: jak szybko schudnac

Pingback: swimming lessons in orlando

Pingback: test kaffeevollautomaten unter 500

Pingback: Download, ME1100, Reset waste ink

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Bail Bonds Zero Down

Pingback: Bustiers

Pingback: M88

Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

Pingback: denver limos

Pingback: Who is Charlie Really?

Pingback: Green tea

Pingback: this site has good information

Pingback: Best Web Hosting Services

Pingback: various posts

Pingback: gratis freespin

Pingback: Ontario

Pingback: zombie gams

Pingback: idiot proof diet

Pingback: fajsdgjfashdjfaksjdhkfa

Pingback: Galaxy Note 4

Pingback: seduction

Pingback: free medical billing software

Pingback: Career in Nursing

Pingback: Kominki i akcesoria

Pingback: skup laptopów Wroclaw

Pingback: win prizes like Wii and ipod, it's fast, easy and fun. join us

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: how long is premature ejaculation

Pingback: Pompy zatapialne

Pingback: uslugi ksiegowe kraków

Pingback: wondershare video converter

Pingback: Pen Scratch Remover

Pingback: WP Dollar 2

Pingback: bankruptcy chapter 13

Pingback: read this

Pingback: drugs that cause premature ejaculation

Pingback: News

Pingback: Bariatric Surgery

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: The Expendables 3 2014 DVDSCR XviD-ViP3R

Pingback: indretningsarkitekt

Pingback: Love story in Hindi

Pingback: Low-cost Online Shopping

Pingback: Go Here

Pingback: More Info

Pingback: Denver DUI Lawyers

Pingback: free movie expendables 3

Pingback: Java Tutorial

Pingback: get a job at mcdonalds

Pingback: Indian Caterer

Pingback: gogol spain

Pingback: click here to investigate

Pingback: go here for review

Pingback: look here

Pingback: low carb diet

Pingback: generic rx drugs

Pingback: online slots

Pingback: her response

Pingback: money making websites

Pingback: learn more,

Pingback: Continued

Pingback: Discover More Here

Pingback: how to lucid dream

Pingback: make money online

Pingback: download hd The Expendables 3

Pingback: Andrzej Grodzki Gdansk

Pingback: his comment is here

Pingback: http://excursionesenelpuertodelacruz.jimdo.com/

Pingback: kod rabatowy

Pingback: download a The Expendables 3

Pingback: Rec Tec Grills

Pingback: fundraising

Pingback: australia online shopping

Pingback: fashion boutique

Pingback: macarons kopen antwerpen

Pingback: arkitekter

Pingback: khol

Pingback: marynarki meskie

Pingback: how to get a guy to last longer in bed

Pingback: news headlines of 2014

Pingback: sexleksakr

Pingback: ionized water

Pingback: federal tax crimes

Pingback: Tanning Lotion

Pingback: home loans Dunwoody

Pingback: news

Pingback: Website Design in Romford

Pingback: banned commercials

Pingback: xxx goats

Pingback: quality products

Pingback: urban

Pingback: investing in gold

Pingback: Demir Leather

Pingback: computer sales

Pingback: paleo recipe book

Pingback: tips

Pingback: lovelady center donations

Pingback: charleston storage loft bed]

Pingback: ecommerce site

Pingback: Packers and Movers in Mumbai

Pingback: criminal lawyer

Pingback: fiverr backlinks

Pingback: renting apartment in madrid

Pingback: garage epoxy

Pingback: бесплатно Неудержимые 3 скачать сайты

Pingback: ego-t

Pingback: Olen Taydus

Pingback: catch a cheating girlfriend

Pingback: The Begum Law Group

Pingback: scent markers for blind dogs

Pingback: moving company

Pingback: cam

Pingback: Discount coupons

Pingback: live ladyboys

Pingback: 360ISO REVIEW

Pingback: read more

Pingback: water heater installation conroe tx

Pingback: FX trading Education

Pingback: Exchange

Pingback: buy cuban cigars online

Pingback: cancer hats

Pingback: crafts with contact paper